9. Sex
offences against children, including online abuse
The number
of child sex offenders
9.1 It is not possible to say with any certainty how many
active child sex offenders there are in the UK. Over 18,000
individuals, the vast majority men, are currently registered
as sex offenders. This figure includes those responsible
for offences against adults. However, the Sex Offenders'
Register holds the details only of those offenders convicted,
cautioned or released from prison for prescribed child and
adult offences after September 1997. A
recent UK law enforcement investigation (Operation Ore)
revealed that a significant proportion of the 7,000 UK subscribers
to a particular group of internet websites offering access
to images of child abuse were previously unknown to the
police. This points to the limitations of the registration
system as a guide to the level of child sex offending in
the UK.
The
number of victims
9.2 Arriving at a reliable figure for the number of victims
in the UK is also problematical. Between 1980 and 2001, almost
70,000 crimes were reported involving gross indecency with
a child and unlawful sexual intercourse with a female child.
However, there is a concern
that many instances of sexual abuse go unreported, with some
estimates putting this as high as 95 percent.
Underreporting occurs for a number of reasons. Young victims
are less likely to report abuse, independent witnesses are
rare, and victims can be intimidated or have misplaced feelings
of guilt or embarrassment. The fact that victims often report
abuse historically, once they have reached adulthood, means
that a sex offender may be active over a long period of time
before coming to the attention of the authorities. This allows
offenders to commit multiple offences against more than one
victim before authorities become aware of them.
The
impact on the victims
9.3 The psychological impact on the victims of child sexual
abuse varies from case to case. For some there may be no outward
signs of the abuse having affected them, but for others it
has resulted in alcoholism, petty crime, mental health problems
and, in extreme cases, suicide. Experiencing abuse as a child
is also a risk factor that may influence whether someone becomes
an offender. However, there is no proven causal link
and there are a number of other risk factors.
The
profile of child sex offenders
9.4 Child sex offenders do not fit a standard profile. They
come from all social and ethnic backgrounds and any walk of
life. They have varying levels of intelligence and
interpersonal skills. Some are obsessive collectors and keep
detailed diaries and pictures of children and catalogue their
activities and fantasies. In the UK, by far the majority
are adult white men. Although
women make up only a small percentage of offenders, a larger
number knowingly or otherwise facilitate child sex offences
by providing access to their children or overlooking abuse.
This usually occurs when the women herself is vulnerable,
either economically or emotionally. Some offenders have a
preference for children of a particular age, sex or appearance,
while others will target any child. Most
offenders in treatment programmes report that they became
aware of a sexual attraction towards children before the age
of 18.
Targeting
and controlling victims, including 'grooming'
9.5 It is relatively uncommon for child sex offenders to abduct
children, though there are instances of this, including a
number of high profile cases where the child has subsequently
been murdered. However, the
evidence indicates that most child sex offenders abuse their
own children, stepchildren, or others with whom they have
a family relationship. Ease of access clearly
plays a part, as does trust. Offenders can be inventive in
the way obtain access to children. For example, they
may target single mothers by placing or responding to advertisements
in 'lonely hearts' columns.
9.6
Offenders often frequent places where children congregate,
such as schools, arcades, coastal resorts, churches and stations.
As confirmed by Operation Ore, some seek employment, or voluntary
work, that brings them into contact with children. Others
may take up certain hobbies for the same reason. While a system
of pre-employment vetting has been introduced for those working
children and young adults in order to deal with this threat,
it can only be effective where there is a record of offending
and where the identity of the person being vetted is assured.
9.7
Offenders, especially those with good social skills, often
prime and control their victims through a process known as
'grooming', which can occur over a short period or over a
number of years. Grooming has the dual purpose
of securing the cooperation of the victim, and sometimes that
of the victim's carers, and of reducing the risk of discovery
or disclosure by creating an atmosphere of normality and acceptance.
The latter can pose difficulties once offences come to light,
with victims refusing to cooperate with an investigation,
believing that the offender has done nothing wrong. Some offenders
are known to show children images of child abuse and adult
pornography to make their victims more susceptible to abuse.
Victims have also been groomed to introduce further victims
to the process of grooming and abuse.
9.8
Most child sex offenders look to control their victims through
the giving or withholding of rewards, whether in the form
of gifts or attention. Some use actual violence or psychological
threats to ensure cooperation. For example, a child may be
told that he or she will be put into care. Often,
offenders exploit the victim's sense of guilt by persuading
the child that he or she led the abuser on.
The
nature and extent of organised child sex offending Networking
9.9 Most identified child sex
offenders act alone. Organised groups are
relatively rare. However, there
is extensive criminal networking. Offenders network in order
to exchange indecent images and fantasies, to gain access
to victims, and to justify and 'normalise' their offending.
For example, networks provide positive reinforcement
that child pornography is acceptable. Where offenders are
able to establish relationships with like-minded individuals,
for example through being imprisoned together, it is possible
for networks to form. However, the arrival of the
internet has changed the nature and extent of networking.
The internet makes it possible to network on a much wider
scale and, if security measures are taken, with less risk.
Online guides to all aspects of child sex are available. Some
have hyper-links to bulletin boards, information about chat
rooms, where IT expertise and access or grooming techniques
are shared, and passwords or pass-phrases given to access
pornography.
9.10
Most online child sex networks
are hierarchical in structure and secretive, with access by
invitation only. Individuals may be approached in chat rooms
and invited to join a network. Often there is a vetting process,
with status and trust being gained by evidence of illegal
activity. Protecting themselves against law
enforcement is a key concern, and some online child sex offenders
openly discuss methods for keeping their activities from the
police. There is also evidence that online networks undertake
counter-intelligence activity, researching techniques used
by the police and internet watch groups by debriefing people
who have been arrested. Some members are aware of surveillance
techniques and take steps to avoid being followed. If an offender
puts members of the network at risk, perhaps by the unauthorised
passing on of images, he is likely to have his computer targeted
with viruses or denial of service attacks.
Grooming
through the internet
9.11 Some child sex offenders
use internet chatrooms (or ICQ/Instant messaging)
to target and groom children, looking to encourage the child
to supply indecent images of themselves, or text of a sexual
nature, or ultimately to meet up. A number of offenders have
shown themselves adept at manipulating the children they contact,
winning their trust by pretending to understand and share
their interests and feelings. The anonymity of the
internet allows adult offenders to misrepresent themselves
as young children or more often teenagers, making
it easier for them to establish a bond. In some cases, children
have been duped into meeting up with offenders, who have then
attempted to abuse them sexually, sometimes successfully.
Images
of child abuse
9.12 Some experts believe that viewing images of child
abuse allows offenders to normalise their sexual feelings
and break down any barriers of guilt and fear which prevent
them from physically offending. Whatever the precise
link between viewing images and committing child sex acts,
possessing the images is an offence in itself. Moreover,
the demand for new images encourages producers to find new
victims or to repeat the abuse of existing victims.
Production of images usually
involves abuse of a child, although
some images of adults are altered through a process known
as 'morphing'. The internet has enabled
a rapid growth in the publication of computer-based images
of child abuse and their global distribution. Computer-based
images of child abuse have now largely replaced printed material.
9.13
The Internet Watch Foundation (IWF) disseminates intelligence
on websites containing images of child abuse to law enforcement,
and liaises with UK Internet Service Providers, so that illegal
material can be removed from their servers. In 2002,
the number of reports made to the IWF increased by 64 percent.
Over half of all illegal websites known to the IWF
are hosted in the USA, although the number in Russia has more
than doubled (from 286 to 706). However,
sites may be hosted in one country and managed from elsewhere.
This creates significant difficulties for law enforcement,
not least in identifying and tracing the victims who feature
in images of child abuse. Often there are no leads for research
into the victims' identity or the location of the abuse. However,
the National Crime Squad's Childbase initiative is an attempt
to tackle the problem by analysing seized images.
9.14
It is possible that a relatively small number of offenders,
either individually or operating in networks, are responsible
for the production of large quantities of child pornography.
Some may distribute it for pleasure rather than profit via
newsgroups, peer2peer networks, fileservers, non-payment internet
sites and community groups. However,
the potential profits to be made from selling images of child
abuse online has also attracted serious and organised criminals.
Advances in internet technology mean that it is now also used
to show real-time video coverage of abuse simultaneously to
a number of viewers.
Sex
tourism
9.15 Some British child sex offenders travel abroad in order
to abuse children. Some may take victims with them, some are
known to prearrange access to victims, usually via the internet,
but most seek out places where they will have easy access
to children, including child prostitutes. In doing so, they
are, of course, hoping to escape detection by UK authorities.
If successful, as well as the crimes committed abroad, the
risk they pose in the UK may also increase should they become
more confident in their child sex offender activities.
9.16
The attraction of particular countries relates to
a number of factors, includinga
low age of consent or tolerance of sex with children,
inadequate legislation or poorly resourced law enforcement
and an established sex industry.
Poverty is also an important factor and countries where natural
or economic disaster has created large numbers of vulnerable
children are likely to attract child sex offenders.
Some
child sex offenders deliberately target countries where children
are less physically developed for their age. British child
sex offenders are known to have travelled widely, including
Eastern Europe (particularly the Czech Republic and
Romania), South East Asia (particularly Thailand, Cambodia,
the Philippines, and increasingly Vietnam), India (Goa), Brazil
and Cuba. Spain and Greece are also popular
because they have a lower age of consent than the UK and it
is relatively easy for child sex offenders to travel there.
9.17
Although other countries may seem to be more attractive destinations
than the UK for sex tourists, there is some evidence that
foreign nationals have travelled to Britain and committed
sex offences. This implies that there is a gap in the arrangements
for managing sex offenders since foreign sex offenders are
not required to register in the UK (although this will be
dealt with in the new Sex Offences Act). It is possible that
foreign offenders will not come to the attention of the UK
authorities and that even if they become known, there may
be insufficient information to conduct a reliable risk assessment
or pre-employment checks.
Combatting
re-offending by child sex offenders
9.18 Various measures have been introduced in the UK to deal
with child sex offenders. Most measures focus on combating
re-offending, as in the case of the treatment of offenders.
Prison treatment programmes are run for convicted child sex
offenders, although the numbers of offenders and the resource-intensive
nature of the treatment mean that it is in limited supply.
Post-release treatment is also extremely important,
since re-offending rates may increase when offenders feel
insecure and isolated and are not provided with the strategies
and skills to address their offending behaviour. The Probation
Service in England and Wales is reviewing and improving the
range of community treatment programmes. However, the success
of any treatment programme depends heavily on the willingness
of the offender to participate.
9.19
Other measures involve monitoring the whereabouts
and activities of offenders. Child (and adult) sex
offenders who have committed an offence since 1997, or were
in custody at that time, are required to register their name
and address with the police for a specified period under the
Sex Offenders Act 1997. The levels of compliance are very
high. However, some offenders deliberately pursue
an itinerant lifestyle in order to avoid registration, either
to make re-offending easier or through fear of vigilantism.
Failure to comply with the requirement to register is a criminal
offence. Meanwhile, the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 enables
police forces to apply for Sex Offender Orders prohibiting
an offender from prescribed activities and locations.
9.20
Released sex offenders who are judged to pose a high risk
to the public are managed by the police and Probation Service
in England and Wales through Multi-Agency Public Protection
Arrangements (MAPPA). Similar but non-statutory arrangements
exist in Scotland and Northern Ireland. MAPPA are supported
by legislation and national guidelines. Each police force
area has MAPPA Panels, consisting of senior police and Probation
Service officers, and often involving other agencies such
as Social Services and local housing authorities. However,
most child sex offenders are not managed through MAPPA and
there are no common standards for their management. To address
this, the police service has invested in an IT-based management
tool, known as ViSOR, that pools information on sex offenders.
9.21
Measures aimed at preventing child sex offenders from obtaining
jobs where they pose a risk to children are based around pre-employment
vetting. For example, there are procedures for educational
institutions to check whether prospective teachers have a
record for misconduct. Meanwhile, the Criminal Records Bureau,
established in 2002, offers employers the ability to check
whether potential employees looking to work with children
have previous convictions.
relevé
de http://www.ncis.co.uk/ukta/2003/threat09.asp
|